The Evidence Effect

The unique value of aid and philanthropy—four essential roles

A woman harvesting rice in a field.

Governments and local communities are leading the charge on delivering services at scale. When focused on the right things, donor capital—both bilateral and philanthropic—doesn’t have to and generally shouldn’t replace government funding. It should play a catalytic role to spark innovation, spread learning, scale game-changing solutions, and strengthen responsible governments. 

Read the fifth post in our Evidence Effect series

Evidence in action

The Evidence Effect highlights examples of life-changing programs that warrant more attention, investment, and consideration for scaling. Explore them below, drawn from more than 1,200 completed randomized evaluations led by researchers in our network.

Bringing crop innovation from the lab to farmers’ fields

Flood-tolerant seeds help farmers adapt to extreme weather without sacrificing their yields, making investing in change worthwhile. 

Effective and fair taxation

Governments can adopt high- and low-tech approaches to raise resources through improved taxation.

Mobile phone monitoring for better government services

Phone-based monitoring is a cheap, accessible way to ensure government service providers are doing their jobs well.

An AI assistant for teachers

An AI-powered editing tool gave students personalized feedback and helped teachers spend more of their time one-on-one with students.

Helping workers get justice

Customizing information and offering mediation helped Mexico’s labor courts deliver faster, fairer resolutions for workers and led to a major national reform.

A market to clean up air pollution

How India used cap-and-trade to reduce pollution and improve health.

Giving cash with conditions

A dual strategy to alleviate poverty: Attaching conditions to cash transfers can provide immediate financial assistance while helping families invest in their children's future. 

Giving cash simply works

When low-income families receive cash with no strings attached, their lives improve in measurable ways. 

Government innovation to improve social services

Providing vulnerable households with accurate, timely information about their benefits can help improve access and increase government efficiency. 

Abhijit Banerjee and Esther Duflo joint headshot

The objectives of aid are often unclear.... Reaffirming the most basic principle would provide clarity: The goal should be to invest in projects that will have the largest impact on the quality of life of poor people around the world.

—Abhijit Banerjee and Esther Duflo, The Financial Times, March 2025

Discover more perspectives from the J-PAL network

 


Photos: 

(1) Two farmers uproot rice seedlings for transplantation during monsoon season in India. Credit: Shutterstock.com

(2) A woman laughs as an enumerator measures her height in her home in Borong, East Nusa Tenggara, Indonesia. The measurement was part of an impact evaluation of an information campaign focused on preventing malnutrition. Credit: Miranda Putri, J-PAL

(3) Residents purchase rice at subsidized prices at a community hall in Jakarta, Indonesia. Credit: Wulandari Wulandari