Reducing School Violence and Harassment in France

Researchers:
Nina Guyon
Yann Algan
Location:
France
Sample:
13,688 students in 306 schools
Timeline:
2012 - 2014
Research papers:

Partners:

Finding effective strategies to prevent violence and systematic harassment at school can improve student outcomes and wellbeing. Researchers evaluated the effectiveness of two programs aiming to reduce violence and harassment in primary and middle schools in France. Overall, neither program reduced violence or harassment. However, social mediation was effective when the mediator was experienced, and particularly so for students who initially faced higher levels of violence.

Policy issue

Violence and harassment in schools is a pervasive problem in many parts of the world. If left unresolved, it can have an adverse effect on students’ wellbeing, academic achievement, and labor market outcomes. Non-experimental research suggests that children that are victimized by their peers are more likely to suffer from depression and low self-esteem, complete fewer years of schooling, and earn lower wages as adults. Finding effective strategies to reduce school violence and promote a safe learning environment may lead to improved student outcomes.

Context of the evaluation

A recent survey in France of over 12,000 elementary school children aged 8 to 12 revealed that 14 percent of children had been the victims of verbal aggression in school (such as teasing) and 10 percent had been subject to physical violence (such as shoving or hitting). Most of these students were not subject to systematic harassment, but the majority declared suffering from occasional physical and verbal harassment.1

In 2012, France Médiation, a network of organizations working with social mediation, launched the project Médiation Sociale en Milieu Scolaire (“Social Mediation in School”). Mediators were hired by the network’s members and trained by France Médiation. In total, they received 22 days of training on how to recognize situations of violence and harassment in school, mediate conflicts and train others to become mediators. They were between 20 and 59 years of age and had varying prior experience as mediators.

Kids in school
Photo: Shutterstock.com

Details of the intervention

In partnership with France Médiation and French university Sciences Po Paris, researchers evaluated the effectiveness of two programs, Médiation Sociale en Milieu Scolaire (“Social Mediation in School”) and Prise de Conscience (“Raising Awareness”), aimed at reducing school violence and harassment. The study included 306 school sites with a total of 226 primary schools and 80 middle schools.

The evaluation used a two-step randomization approach:

First, researchers randomly assigned half of the school sites to receive the program Médiation Sociale en Milieu Scolaire, a total of 115 primary schools and 40 middle schools. France Médiation provided a trained social mediator to help prevent and resolve conflicts between students, staff, and students’ parents. Social mediators worked with students and teachers to raise awareness about violence and harassment, helped them solve their conflicts, provided personalized counseling, and trained volunteer teachers and students to become mediators themselves. Mediators spent on average three days per week in middle schools throughout the school year (112 days in total) and half a day per week in primary schools (27 days in total).

Within the remaining school sites, researchers randomly assigned 40 primary schools to receive Prise de Conscience, implemented by Sciences-Po Paris. As part of this program, researchers conducted a survey to assess violence and harassment in school and presented the results to the school staff to encourage them to develop violence prevention and reduction initiatives.

The remaining 71 primary schools and 40 middle schools served as a comparison and received neither program.

Researchers collected administrative data on student performance and attendance, as well as survey data on self-declared violence, harassment, and psychological wellbeing. They also collected information on school staff’s and parents’ perceptions about violence in school.

Results and policy lessons

Overall, neither program reduced violence or harassment levels. However, social mediation was effective when the mediator was experienced, and particularly so for students who initially faced higher levels of violence.

Impact on physical and verbal harassment: Mediation reduced violence and harassment when the mediator was experienced and for students who initially faced higher levels of violence. In middle schools with experienced mediators (aged over 25), the number of students who reported being verbally harassed decreased by 1.6 percentage points (14.5 percent) from an average of 11 percent in the comparison group. Experienced mediators were particularly effective for sixth-grade male students, who were the most exposed to violence and harassment prior to the program. These students witnessed a 6.4 percentage point (46 percent) reduction in harassment from a comparison average of 14 percent.

In primary school, experienced mediators reduced harassment amongst second-grade female students initially exposed to higher levels of violence. However, it had the opposite effect on fourth-grade female students, who were initially less exposed to violence and harassment. Researchers believe mediator support may have led some fourth-grade students to become more aware of violence and harassment, and thus more likely to identify those situations.

Impact on psychological wellbeing: Experienced mediators improved the psychological wellbeing of middle-school students who initially faced higher levels of violence. Sixth-grade male students were less likely to wake up in the middle of the night, to feel bored, or to be scared.

Teacher and student absenteeism: Social mediation reduced teacher and student absenteeism in middle school, but had no impact in primary school. Middle schools with social mediators were half as likely to have at least one teacher absent per day (22 percent of schools), compared to the comparison group’s average of 50 percent. When exposed to experienced mediators, sixth-grade boys were 4.9 percentage points (31 percent) less likely to skip class, compared to a comparison group average of 16 percent.

Researchers believe social mediation performed better in middle school than in primary school because mediators spent more time with the teachers and students (three days per week in middle school compared to half a day per week in primary school). In primary school, the mediation program led to better knowledge and awareness about violence and harassment, but did not last long enough to help students solve their conflicts or become mediators, themselves.

Overall, these results suggest that the profile of mediators and the amount of time spent in schools are key determinants of the effectiveness of social mediation.

Algan, Yann, Guyon, Nina, and Elise Huillery. 2015. “Comment lutter contre la violence et le harcèlement à l’école et au collège ?: Effets du dispositif de médiation sociale France Médiation et d’un dispositif de prise de conscience du niveau de violence.” Sciences Po Publications.

1.
UNICEF and Observatoire International de la Violence à l’Ecole. 2011. "À l’École des enfants heureux… enfin presque." https://www.unicef.fr/sites/default/files/userfiles/UNICEF_FRANCE_violences_scolaires_mars_2011.pdf.