The Double Burden: Coethnic Discrimination in Refugee-Hosting States
Coethnic networks often help refugees integrate more easily into host societies. However,
these same ties can become a source of vulnerability for coethnic host citizens, who may face increased discrimination from both the state and broader society. This project asks: When refugees and violent actors (e.g., the Taliban) share an ethnic identity with part of the host population (e.g., Pashtuns in Pakistan), what drives discrimination against coethnic host citizens—and can this bias be reduced? Such discrimination may appear both socially—through exclusion and suspicion from non-coethnic citizens—and institutionally, through
arbitrary arrests, surveillance, and heightened police scrutiny. The ongoing deportation of
Afghan refugees from Pakistan, alongside the Pashtun Tahafuz Movement’s protests against state repression of Pakistani Pashtuns, offers a timely context for investigation. The project will proceed in two phases. First, interviews will be conducted with Afghan refugees, Pakistani Pashtuns, non-Pashtun citizens, civil society actors, and law enforcement officials to build a grounded theory of coethnic discrimination. Second, an RCT will be designed to test interventions aimed at reducing bias—such as varying perceived ethnicity in discretionary policing scenarios or piloting law enforcement trainings with ethnically mixed teams. This project contributes to scholarship on refugee-host relations, ethnic violence, and state discrimination. It addresses a major gap in existing research, which often treats host populations as either fully distinct from or fully coethnic with refugees, overlooking realities of multiethnic states. It also offers practical insights for policy stakeholders such as UNHCR, IOM, etc. seeking to reduce bias and promote inclusion.